Normally stay well away from all this. I agree with all the arguments about right wing politics being a distraction technique, and that right wing parties worldwide cover up incompetence and mismanagement with dog whistles.
At some point you have to wonder though. If right wing governments are being elected everywhere with their only real message being “reduce immigration”… maybe, democratically, a lot of people don’t really like immigration?
I think you have to recognise that truth whether you agree with it or not, and if you dig down into everything from Brexit to Orban to the rise of far right parties in Europe it comes down to this. And then you have to recognise, what is the point of democracy? Just because people vote for something that’s either unpalatable, economically self harming, for misguided and fearful reasons or all of the above, isn’t it the point to give them what they voted for?
My own point of view is that people are people and of course overwhelmingly, generally good. There’s an enrichment to cultural diversities which is priceless. If you spend time outside of the UK you realise that we’re way better at multiculturalism than most places, and no-one in Italy for instance knows the best recipe for a chicken bhuna or can put together a decent dub reggae playlist off the top of their head.
There’s also a point - like the part of London I used to live in, officially the most diverse few square miles in the country with 120+ languages spoken - where it becomes an absolute nightmare, because everyone is transient, desperate, and (including me!) have no connection, care or interest in the environment or people around them. And, again including me, it’s not like that area got the very best of people from wherever we all came from to end up there, because it was cheap and rough.
This also goes unsaid a lot of the time, because it’s a dangerous topic, but I think you’re also morally obliged to play the hand you’re dealt with re colonialism / history’s impact on your 21st century population. It’s like a moral tax for that country’s contribution to your current country’s prosperity. I would never, ever look down on Jamaican or Indian / Pakistani / Bangladeshi / Canadian immigrants as “not British”. A French Arab is as French as the white farmer with a baguette hanging off his bike. I also think it’s reasonable for someone in, say, Sweden, to look at, say, France or Belgium, and the level of social instability caused there by immigration from Islamic countries (let’s say, it because it’s true) and think, I don’t want any part of that.
(Am aware that all governments need immigration because of ageing populations and increasing the tax base with affordable workers who are a net economic positive. The difference is the sleight of hand they use to pretend they’re not doing it.
Am also deeply aware of the irony of the “Stop the Boats” party being the one who have
added 2 million immigrants in 3 years.)