Sheriff_John_Bunnell_ret
Well-known member
It isn't a straw man argument in the slightest. Clubs lose players for reasons outside their control all the time. The idea that it would be "fairer" to void an entire season on this basis is ludicrous.
It isn't a straw man argument in the slightest. Clubs lose players for reasons outside their control all the time. The idea that it would be "fairer" to void an entire season on this basis is ludicrous.
We're just going to have to fundamentally disagree, because to me the situations are in no way comparable.
I also don't think it should have been voided, I think it should have been decided by PPG.
Was it unfair to let the clubs vote?