Giles wasn't the only player exposed yesterday, Smith was getting run ragged, as were many others, Brighton are a top side, they can tear teams apart for fun, and we must realise the gap between the two leagues is massive.
Giles has been a great attacking left back for us, he has the best crossing ability in this league by far.
However his defensive qualities are lacking, and he is more exposed with better opposition we play against (hence why he isn't playing in the premier league) but he will help us in the championship against most teams.
I disagree with many posters wanting to sign him on a permanent deal now, best to keep him on loan and see where we end up, if we get promoted then we need a better option, he would be targeted by better opposition in the premiership, if we don't go up then maybe try and loan him again, he is a good championship player, but I do think that's his level.