I’m too young to have seen him, but would go Hickton, just because of the way my dad recalls his penalties so romantically. Run ups from the half way line etc. Legends that make football great!
(Would go Grant out of those in my lifetime)
My grandad used to say Lindy Delapenha, and used to mention one that broke a hole in the net, that cleary went in the goal, in front of the holgate end, and the ref gave a goal kick.