agreed, I'm 99% confident we would have achieved the play offs, 55% confident of doing Leeds at that point but 10% on beating Villa in a final. That's just my view and every one would have a view some wildly different. However would Gibson be this dogmatic if he didn't feel he had a case? He is acting like he did with Liverpool, dog with a bone, he won that won....or would have but they folded before court. The case isn't 100% without merit, we can't really say that without being privy to what the evidence or even what the actual case that has been filed looks like. At this point it's all opinions