I am one of the very few that was gutted he had been sacked. I felt disappointment that Gibson did that. I understand many wanted him sacked before we were relegated never mind after relegation was confirmed.
I have said that he was the wrong appointment in 2006. I personally felt he was not his own man and do not believe he was in charge of recruitment, especially given his lack of experience. I have no doubt he was involved in the process and from everything we have seen since we know the ‘head coach’ does not always get their way it would seem.
It seems to me Southgate was the cheap option who was popular with the fans and gave the owner time to implement the cost cutting from the McClaren years. We seemingly had a lot of players who were at a senior stage in the careers whose value had to be realised or wage bills slashed
Queudrue was sold for £3M, being replaced by the inferior Arca although admittedly we paid £6M for Huth that summer, the clearout began in earnest in the winter, Ehiogu, Parlour and Maccarone all given free transfers, followed by Viduka, Xavier, Christie all off the wage bill along with Parnaby and Graham
We sold Yakubu replaced him with Mido, bought Woodgate but quickly sold him a few months later bought and sold Luke Young within the year, Southgate did exceptionally well with the huge turnover that was taking place in those first two seasons in charge imho. Loads of players left either out of contract or on frees a few were sold for good money and replaced by inferior players, some nevertheless for good money Mido for £6M ….. Where was due dilligence with him? Alves £13.5M for a player who allegedly struggled to read and write?
The year we were relegated the squad we had was brittle, it lacked leadership, it was full of individuals who had no fight or backbone, only Pog and Huth had any fight. We were so lightweight in the midfield and upfront. We dropped like a stone from November, playing 13 games without a win, stopping the rot with an unexpected win at home over Liverpool, an own goal set up that win. Southgate was set up to fail imho, not deliberately, but he was naive in his managerial years at Boro but I am sure he gave his best given his lot. I thought he was treated badly and was in part taken advantage off in terms of the wheeling and dealing. I know he was bitter about his sacking. Lita seemed to believe that he was respected, liked and the players were behind him. Lamb said he approached Strachan after the Coventry draw, which was a few weeks before Southgates sacking, which makes it all very odd.
If it was for football reasons, it should have been on relegation, not after a home victory one point of the top. Some time after his sacking Southgate was suggesting he didn’t have full control over all the transfers Alves for one, which Lamb later denied however. Could the transfer policy have been behind a fall-out that ultimately sealed his fate? We will never know i guess, different fans have different perceptions and views on that time. Lita said nothing to dissuade me from my thoughts on the matter if anything strengthening my thoughts.
Lita’s views on managers and changing rooms throws some light on how managers can make or break a team and affect their performances though, probably more so nowadays as players are less afraid of managers and will not take to the methods of old.