Red Faction disgraceful today

Much bigger risk to safety than a fan running on the pitch after we scored a late winner. The punishment should be at least the same.
 
Just a question - how many examples have we had of a flare causing a problem (other than a 13k fine)?
And, I don’t class ‘outrage’ as a problem
Come on finny you’re better than that, just a single health issue is more than enough. Would it make the argument against more valid if it had killed someone suffering from asthma, COPD or another lung disorder, you shouldn’t need a tragedy to think it a bad idea. I’m mentioning you because you’re a good poster and I usually like you have to say.

Here’s a few examples of them going wrong, many of these victims are little kids. There’s many more I just picked some from the first couple of pages off a google search.











 
Last edited:
They were a bit stupid setting the thing off under the banner. I don’t know what the banner is made with but I reckon it’s flammable! If that had lit it could have been nasty.
 
It's not allowed for obvious safety reasons, the culprit should be banned simple as that....

What do all those blokes in white shirts do in that room at the top of the South Stand ?
Aren't they supposed to be monitoring the crowd ?
 
It did look great and momentarily lifted the atmosphere inside the stadium.

I do agree though that for health and safety reasons, they shouldn't be letting them off inside the stadium.

Let's not turn against the Red Faction though. Without them the stadium would be like a morgue. Punish the individuals who were directly responsible and let's move on.
 
I’d simply ban everyone with a seat in and around the area with it. They should be able to pinpoint whose seats were where it was at and anyone else around if they don’t give up the guilty one, two or whoever, ban them for being an accomplice. Ignorant tw@ts the lot of them, deserve to be made an example of.
 
It did look great and momentarily lifted the atmosphere inside the stadium.

I do agree though that for health and safety reasons, they shouldn't be letting them off inside the stadium.

Let's not turn against the Red Faction though. Without them the stadium would be like a morgue. Punish the individuals who were directly responsible and let's move on.

It was an organised display from Red Faction, the flare was central to it, so that would surely be banning dozens to hundreds.

I don't think they should be banned, but then I don't think that fan should have been banned for life on Saturday either and he endangered nobody (except in the hypothetical).
 
It did look great and momentarily lifted the atmosphere inside the stadium.

I do agree though that for health and safety reasons, they shouldn't be letting them off inside the stadium.

Let's not turn against the Red Faction though. Without them the stadium would be like a morgue. Punish the individuals who were directly responsible and let's move on.
Did it really look great though?

I personally thought it was embarrassing and those around me in the north did too. I also heard it being booed.
 
Feels like the reaction is a bit over the top. Hundreds of games pass in Europe every weekend with these sort of displays without incident
Are you unaware of any incidents or do you genuinely believe there are none? Could it just be that they’re not being reported very often or you’re not looking to find out?
 
It was an organised display from Red Faction, the flare was central to it, so that would surely be banning dozens to hundreds.

I don't think they should be banned, but then I don't think that fan should have been banned for life on Saturday either and he endangered nobody (except in the hypothetical).
Yes true, this is where it becomes tricky. I certainly wouldn't want to see lifetime bans dished out, especially to hundreds of fans.

I appreciate the club wish to enforce a zero tolerance stance with regards to pyrotechnics and fans entering the pitch, but the consequences of this could actually be detrimental to the club and the rest of us. The last thing we would want to happen would be for the Red Faction to boycott the Riverside.
 
Back
Top