You are Kieran Scott, what would you do?

Left_peg

Well-known member
Everyone has an opinion on where the club have fallen short, what we need to do to progress, who should stay and who should go.

So, put yourself in Scott's position for this summer - who do you target to take us from playoff contenders to automatic promotion candidates and who do you try to flog?

My first order of business would be to send Greenwood, Thomas and O'Brien back to their parent clubs. Even if we're only paying half of their wages that'd be around £30k p/w saved.
Offer Ayling a 1 year contract (£15k p/w).

Allow McNair to leave, not because he's not good but because with Clarke, Lenihan, Fry, VDB as centre backs we are well stocked there and we can use the reported £20k p/w to strengthen other areas of need.
Look to bring in a fee for Dijksteel - he seems to have dropped off a bit this season which is a shame as he was brilliant under Wilder. Carrick doesn't seem to fancy him so makes sense to cash in as he'll be going into the last year of his contract. Current market value of £1.5m but I wouldn't expect to get anywhere near that.
Take whatever we can get for Hoppe. He doesn't look up to the task, get rid and save the £10k p/w wages.
Release Jamie Jones and bring Sol Brynn into the 1st team set up.

Then I'd offer Howson another year extension on same money (believed to be £25k per week). Offer new contracts to Jones, McGree and Clarke who will be going into their final 12 months. Offer a new contract to Rav Van den Berg on improved terms (online sources have him as only being on £2k per week which surely can't be true!)

Try to bring in Will Vaulks from Sheff Wed whose contract expires this summer to be the 4th centre midfielder. 6 foot tall, in the top 6% for defensive actions for defensive midfielders in the division this season. 30 years old so not young, 3 year contract at £15k p/w.

Offer somewhere in the region of £2.5m for Sirike Dembele from Birmingham to be the skillful ball-carrier on the left or just behind the striker. Top 3 for successful dribbles in the championship. Goal involvement stats aren't brilliant but he's playing in a poor team. 27 years old so another 3 year contract at his current salary, again £15k p/w.

Sign Jamal Lowe from Bournemouth (on loan at Swansea) on a free transfer, wages around £12k p/w. 11 goal involvements this season and a decent shot/goal conversion rate. Similar style to Latte Lath so would take us up to 4 strikers with LL, Coburn and Forss.

Bring in Sorba Thomas, top of chances created in the championship this season in a terrible Huddersfield side. Will take a few million in transfer fee but currently only earning around £5k per week so even doubling his money won't put too much strain on the wage bill. 24 years old so in his prime for a quick, wide-player. 4 year contract.

8 out, 6 in (including Ayling in both the out and in, and Brynn counting as coming in). Leaves the squad with 2 less but better balance and also leaves room for young players to be part of the squad and push on. Wage bill would be around the same as this season.
Transfer fees spent = approx £6.5m
Transfer fees received = approx £1m
Net spend = £5.5m

GKs
Dieng
Brynn
Glover

RB
Smith
Ayling

LB
Bangura
Engel

CB
Clarke
Lenihan
Fry
Van den Berg

CM
Howson
Hackney
Vaulks
Barlaser

AM
Jones
Thomas
Dembele

Azaz
McGree
Silvera
Gilbert

CF
Latte Lath
Forss
Lowe
Coburn
 
- Offer Ayling a one year deal and make a bid for O'Brien (no higher than £4m), or try and get him back on loan

- Send Greenwood and Thomas back to respective clubs

- Offer McNair, Howson and Jones' new deals

- Sell Glover, Smith, Djiksteel, Fry and Barlaser

- Send Silvera out on loan to a League One club

- Send Engel out on loan (with the option of recalling him if both LB's are injured)

GK's - Dieng, Brynn

RB's - *New RB*, Ayling

CB's - VDB, Lenihan, Clarke, McNair

LB's - *New LB*, Bangura

CM's - *New DM*, Howson, Hackney, O'Brien

RW's - Forss, Jones

No 10's - *New no 10*, Azaz

LW's - *New LW*, McGree

STs - *New striker*, Lath, Coburn
 
Great posts/options. I'd go down the younger/riskier route...

Harrison Burrows - 22 year old Peterborough LB - team captain - 12 goals and 15 assists this season from full back - probably the best player in league one - might get him for around £3 million.

I'd take his team mate Kwame Poku too - 22 y/o RW - Peterborough would hate me for taking two of their best players but "that's football" - 12 goals and 8 assists this season - £1.5 million~.

Cody Drameh - 22 year old Leeds RB - been on loan at Luton (won promotion), Cardiff and Birmingham - available on a free transfer when his contract runs out.

Luke Ayling - I think he deserves a contract for what he offers both on and off the pitch, good experience pro.

Struggling a little bit with a CDM - I like your Will Vaulks option. I'd also consider Oliver Rathbone - Rotherham captain, will be a free agent in the summer.

I'd be open to re-signing Sam Greenwood if his wages were on par with other players in his position.

I'd also offer both Howson and Jamie Jones another 1 year deal.

Dieng/Glover/Jones

Ayling/Smith/Drameh
RVDB/Fry
Clarke/Lenihan
Burrows/Engel/Bangura

????/Howson
Hackney/Barlasar

Poku/Jones
Azaz/Gilbert
McGree/Greenwood/Silvera

Latte Lathe/Forss/Coburn
 
Great posts/options. I'd go down the younger/riskier route...

Harrison Burrows - 22 year old Peterborough LB - team captain - 12 goals and 15 assists this season from full back - probably the best player in league one - might get him for around £3 million.

I'd take his team mate Kwame Poku too - 22 y/o RW - Peterborough would hate me for taking two of their best players but "that's football" - 12 goals and 8 assists this season - £1.5 million~.

Cody Drameh - 22 year old Leeds RB - been on loan at Luton (won promotion), Cardiff and Birmingham - available on a free transfer when his contract runs out.

Luke Ayling - I think he deserves a contract for what he offers both on and off the pitch, good experience pro.

Struggling a little bit with a CDM - I like your Will Vaulks option. I'd also consider Oliver Rathbone - Rotherham captain, will be a free agent in the summer.

I'd be open to re-signing Sam Greenwood if his wages were on par with other players in his position.

I'd also offer both Howson and Jamie Jones another 1 year deal.

Dieng/Glover/Jones

Ayling/Smith/Drameh
RVDB/Fry
Clarke/Lenihan
Burrows/Engel/Bangura

????/Howson
Hackney/Barlasar

Poku/Jones
Azaz/Gilbert
McGree/Greenwood/Silvera

Latte Lathe/Forss/Coburn
You can see straight away where you and I differ in our opinions of our weak areas! Looks like you've identified full backs as the main area to go and I've gone left wing/striker
 
You can see straight away where you and I differ in our opinions of our weak areas! Looks like you've identified full backs as the main area to go and I've gone left wing/striker

I do agree with your weak areas - CDM/ST are my two main weak areas. I just think Harrison Burrows is too good a player to pass up.

We're also going to have a hole at RB the following season as Smith/Ayling might both leave... Drameh would go some way towards filling that future hole.
 
Last edited:
Everyone has an opinion on where the club have fallen short, what we need to do to progress, who should stay and who should go.

So, put yourself in Scott's position for this summer - who do you target to take us from playoff contenders to automatic promotion candidates and who do you try to flog?

My first order of business would be to send Greenwood, Thomas and O'Brien back to their parent clubs. Even if we're only paying half of their wages that'd be around £30k p/w saved.
Offer Ayling a 1 year contract (£15k p/w).

Allow McNair to leave, not because he's not good but because with Clarke, Lenihan, Fry, VDB as centre backs we are well stocked there and we can use the reported £20k p/w to strengthen other areas of need.
Look to bring in a fee for Dijksteel - he seems to have dropped off a bit this season which is a shame as he was brilliant under Wilder. Carrick doesn't seem to fancy him so makes sense to cash in as he'll be going into the last year of his contract. Current market value of £1.5m but I wouldn't expect to get anywhere near that.
Take whatever we can get for Hoppe. He doesn't look up to the task, get rid and save the £10k p/w wages.
Release Jamie Jones and bring Sol Brynn into the 1st team set up.

Then I'd offer Howson another year extension on same money (believed to be £25k per week). Offer new contracts to Jones, McGree and Clarke who will be going into their final 12 months. Offer a new contract to Rav Van den Berg on improved terms (online sources have him as only being on £2k per week which surely can't be true!)

Try to bring in Will Vaulks from Sheff Wed whose contract expires this summer to be the 4th centre midfielder. 6 foot tall, in the top 6% for defensive actions for defensive midfielders in the division this season. 30 years old so not young, 3 year contract at £15k p/w.

Offer somewhere in the region of £2.5m for Sirike Dembele from Birmingham to be the skillful ball-carrier on the left or just behind the striker. Top 3 for successful dribbles in the championship. Goal involvement stats aren't brilliant but he's playing in a poor team. 27 years old so another 3 year contract at his current salary, again £15k p/w.

Sign Jamal Lowe from Bournemouth (on loan at Swansea) on a free transfer, wages around £12k p/w. 11 goal involvements this season and a decent shot/goal conversion rate. Similar style to Latte Lath so would take us up to 4 strikers with LL, Coburn and Forss.

Bring in Sorba Thomas, top of chances created in the championship this season in a terrible Huddersfield side. Will take a few million in transfer fee but currently only earning around £5k per week so even doubling his money won't put too much strain on the wage bill. 24 years old so in his prime for a quick, wide-player. 4 year contract.

8 out, 6 in (including Ayling in both the out and in, and Brynn counting as coming in). Leaves the squad with 2 less but better balance and also leaves room for young players to be part of the squad and push on. Wage bill would be around the same as this season.
Transfer fees spent = approx £6.5m
Transfer fees received = approx £1m
Net spend = £5.5m

GKs
Dieng
Brynn
Glover

RB
Smith
Ayling

LB
Bangura
Engel

CB
Clarke
Lenihan
Fry
Van den Berg

CM
Howson
Hackney
Vaulks
Barlaser

AM
Jones
Thomas
Dembele

Azaz
McGree
Silvera
Gilbert

CF
Latte Lath
Forss
Lowe
Coburn
Send the 4 loans back .
Dieng £5m and Glover £1m may leave ,
Mcnair will,
Dijksteel likely £500k
Barlaser may move on for 1st team football £1.5m
we can not trust the fitness of Smith and Bangura , so a new pair of full backs .
Lenahan £2m will want 1st team football and may leave to get it .
Mcgree £7m and Forss £4m MAY leave and will need replacing if so.
.( hope not )
Hoppe and Gilbert to go , so 16 potential movers . £21m IN
Brynn and Hemming GK
Norton Cuffy loan or Kesler Hayden £2m RB
Harrison Burrows £2.5m or Max Lowe free LB
Ladislav Krejci £5m LCH , Nathan Wood £2.5mor Michal Helik £2.5m
Alan Browne free CM or Juninho Bacuna £3.5mCM
Sorba Thomas £3.5m RAM
Callum O'hare free AM
Illias Chair £4m
Tyrese Dolan free AM
Jay Stansfield £5m CF or Saldanha £5m CF or Chytil £3m CF
£21.5m - £23m out MAX . OUTLAY £1.5m - £3.5m OR
£19m if we went for Cuffy and Lowe . NO MONEY SPENT .
Some turn over again even if Lenahan and Barlaser stay .

Outcome - Gibbo over the moon to get a squad upgrade and promotion winning squad without spending any of the Rogers / Crooks money , Scott gets an OBE for services given and is then poached by Liverpool.
 
Last edited:
Send the 4 loans back .
Dieng £5m and Glover £1m may leave ,
Mcnair will,
Barlaser may move on for 1st team football £1.5m
we can not trust the fitness of Smith and Bangura , so a new pair of full backs .
Lenahan £2m will want 1st team football and may leave to get it .
Mcgree £7m and Forss £4m MAY leave and will need replacing if so.
.( hope not )
Hoppe and Gilbert to go , so 15 potential movers . £20.5m IN
Brynn and Hemming GK
Norton Cuffy loan or Kesler Hayden £2m RB
Harrison Burrows £2.5m or Max Lowe free LB
Ladislav Krejci £4m LCH or Michal Helik £2.5m
Alan Browne free CM or Juninho Bacuna £3m CM
Sorba Thomas £3m RAM
Callum O'hare free AM
Illias Chair £4m
Jay Stansfield £5m CF or Saldanha £5m CF or Chytil £3m CF
£21.5m - £23m out MAX . OUTLAY £1.5m - £3.5m OR
£19m if we went for Cuffy and Lowe . NO MONEY SPENT .
Some turn over again even if Lenahan and Barlaser stay .

Crack me up your posts, transfer fees you pluck from thin air are class
 
--------------------------------Brynn
------------------_VDB -----Clarke----Krejci
--------BN Cuffy -----Bacuna---Browne ---Lowe/ Burrows
------------------Saldanha---Chytil ---Lathe

£16.5m spend , £5m Krejci, £3m Chytil , £5m Saldanha , £3.5m Bacuna, and Cuffy loan , 3 free in Browne , Lowe , O'hare

-------------------------------Hemming
-------------------Lenahan------Fry-----Helik
--------Jones---------Howson --Hackney-----Chair
-------------- -Thomas----Coburn -----Stansfield


sign Helik
Danny Armstrong £1m , Harvey Knibbs £1m ,Sam Gallagher free Finn Azeez free the cheaper options .
Edited for Diego who rightly pointed out Smith and Bangura are not ok in a back 3 , and Azaz is not a LF, can't fit him in now. Keep though .
 
Last edited:
Langstaff will be available for a reasonable offer, although it's a calculated risk whether he could hack the Championship.
 
I'd recognise that success in my job is just improving the finances so I'll sell all our best players for big money and buy a load of PL academy rejects and go on the radio and tell everyone that this season will be an important transitional season for the club to lower expectations.
 
Try to bring in Will Vaulks from Sheff Wed whose contract expires this summer to be the 4th centre midfielder. 6 foot tall, in the top 6% for defensive actions for defensive midfielders in the division this season. 30 years old so not young, 3 year contract at £15k p/w.
Wears number 4 - good number for a defensive midfielder. Maybe we will have a vacancy at that number for him here
 
Really really poor. Azaz left wing back and Smith and Bangura in a back 3. You watched them play mate?
Yes go every week , and your right , I shoehorned them In to fill spaces . Azaz is a no10 ,but not a good one ATM , but in that formation no no 10 ,
Swap Smith for Lenahan
Bangura for Michal Helik or Harrison Burrows
Azaz for Harvey Knibbs , or Stansfield and put Danny Armstrong RW.
But , the 3 are our players , we won't get rid so are stuck. That's why they are back ups .
 
Last edited:
"You are Kieran Scott, what would you do?"

This is easy to answer, I'd ask Nobby for a look at his notebook.
 
Back
Top