Colin Warnek
Well-known member
After an excellent start he's regressed so badly that even 1.5m wouldn't be a good deal.
Will he? I doubt that very much.Silvera wouldn't have got through 90 mins after flying back from Aus and don't give me Gilbert....... his first contribution yesterday, he will be gone in the summer.
What have you seen to make you think that? He can't get in the squad, doesn't look like a striker nor a winger and certainly isn't getting in our midfield. So where does that leave him?Will he? I doubt that very much.
Definitely one for the future.
I think he has checked out of the MFC ‘hotel’ so to speak….probably knows he hasn’t done enough to warrant a good offer and is mentally elsewhere which shows in his game….I watched him closely today and his work rate was very poor, spent most of the game strolling about and watching when we were under pressure!
He isn’t ready to be starting, yesterday would have boosted him no end. Let’s have some patience with our players.What have you seen to make you think that? He can't get in the squad, doesn't look like a striker nor a winger and certainly isn't getting in our midfield. So where does that leave him?
He has nothing going for him at all.Greenwood definitely has ability, at £1.5m I’d take him but if I was Kieron Scott I’d be looking elsewhere first.
When he starts he's always the first player Carrick hooks.Why do you think Carrick keeps him on then, genuinely? Didn't need to start him today either.
Nothing going for him at all, yet only Forss of our current squad has more goal contributions this seasonHe has nothing going for him at all.
He cant control the ball, when he does he runs down blind alleys.
He runs around a lot but thats only so he can constantly foul someone.
I wouldnt give 1.5p for him.
Send him back now
He hasn’t scored for over three and a half months. He hasn’t made a goal since the middle of January. 4 of his 5 goals came in a 5 week burst between October 7th and November 11th. 2 of his 3 assists came in back-to-back fixtures pushing four months ago.Nothing going for him at all, yet only Forss of our current squad has more goal contributions this season
Oh yeah, he's had a poor spell since Christmas, no doubt about that. But he's a young player in his first full season as a regular, wouldn't we expect that?He hasn’t scored for over three and a half months. He hasn’t made a goal since the middle of January. 4 of his 5 goals came in a 5 week burst between October 7th and November 11th. 2 of his 3 assists came in back-to-back fixtures pushing four months ago.
A poor spell… or a third of the season? I would expect a young player to experience patches of good, bad and indifferent form but save for a 5-6 week spell in Autumn we’ve had precious little out of him.Oh yeah, he's had a poor spell since Christmas, no doubt about that. But he's a young player in his first full season as a regular, wouldn't we expect that?
I think that's harsh. He took a bit of time to settle into the side, then established himself and was good up until probably the Sunderland game in January. He's faded since then but hasn't been alone in that. If he'd come through our academy rather than being on loan from Leeds I think opinions would be different on his progress.A poor spell… or a third of the season? I would expect a young player to experience patches of good, bad and indifferent form but save for a 5-6 week spell in Autumn we’ve had precious little out of him.
He’s 22 though. If he was 18 or 19 and in his breakthrough season you’d be impressed with his contributions. But he’s not a young boy. He drifts through games and hasn’t really developed into anything imo. Is he better now than when we signed him? I’m not sure he is. There’s little or no evidence to suggest he is. He had a really good burst and then drifted out of it. He’s more likely to get booked than score a goal at the moment.I think that's harsh. He took a bit of time to settle into the side, then established himself and was good up until probably the Sunderland game in January. He's faded since then but hasn't been alone in that. If he'd come through our academy rather than being on loan from Leeds I think opinions would be different on his progress.
Yeah but it is his first full season. One year older than Pharrell Willis. If Willis breaks into the team next season and is 2nd in the goal contributions charts but fades after xmas I think we'll be delighted.He’s 22 though. If he was 18 or 19 and in his breakthrough season you’d be impressed with his contributions. But he’s not a young boy. He drifts through games and hasn’t really developed into anything imo. Is he better now than when we signed him? I’m not sure he is. There’s little or no evidence to suggest he is. He had a really good burst and then drifted out of it. He’s more likely to get booked than score a goal at the moment.
I guess we were hoping to see him step up and show more and convince us to buy him. I think he’s still two years away from being a quality champ player. I’ve switched to the don’t bother buying him campI would much rather start Gilbert or Silvera over Greenwood who just strolls about, at least they are our players. I would send Greenwood back now !