Team changes from one season to the next

NeilInFrance

Well-known member
I was shocked by how many changes there were on Saturday compared to our side last season, so thought I would look into historical teams at the beginning of the season compared to the team that started the first game of the following season .

On average - from Millwall vs Boro in 2018 to Boro vs Millwall in 2023 - there have been just 6 players the same from the last game of the season to the first game the next season. So only having 5 of the same players saturday vs the last playoff game against Coventry was not that extraordinary. It is on average nearly half the team that changes.

More encouragingly, there is a bigger difference between the first and last game of the same season; 4.8 of the same player on average


Same players
Milwall04/08/2023F5DiengMcNairFryLenihanCoulsonHackneyBarlaserForssCrooksMcGreeRogers
Coventry17/05/2023L4SteffenSmithMcNairLenihanGillesHackneyMowattForssAkpomMcGreeArcher
West Brom 30/07/2022F6SteffenDijksteelLenihanBolaJonesCrooksHowsonMcGreeGillesWatmoreAkpom
Preston07/05/2022L5DanielsDijksteelFryMcNairJonesCrooksHowsonMcGreeTavernierWatmoreSporar
Bristol City08/08/2021F5LumleyDijksteelHallFryBolaCrooksHowsonMcNairJonesIkpeazuSpence
Wycombe08/05/2021L6ArcherMcNairHallBolaSpenceHowsonSavilleJohnsonCoulsonWatmoreBolasie
Watford11/09/2020F7BettineliDijksteelHallMcNairSpenceHowsonSavilleTavernierJohnsonFletcherAssombalonga
Sheffield Wed22/07/2020L4StojanovicDijksteelFriendFrySpenceTavernierMcNairSavilleJohnsonFletcherAssombalonga
Luton02/08/2019F7Randolph HowsonAyalaShottonCoulsonWingClaytonMcNairJohnsonFletcherAssombalonga
Rotherham05/05/2019L5Randolph McNairFlintShottonHowsonWingObi MikelBesicSavilleFletcherAssombalonga
Milwall04/08/2018F
Randolph ShottonFlintFryFriendClaytonLeadbitterHowsonDowningAssombalongaBraithwaite
 
I was shocked by how many changes there were on Saturday compared to our side last season, so thought I would look into historical teams at the beginning of the season compared to the team that started the first game of the following season .

On average - from Millwall vs Boro in 2018 to Boro vs Millwall in 2023 - there have been just 6 players the same from the last game of the season to the first game the next season. So only having 5 of the same players saturday vs the last playoff game against Coventry was not that extraordinary. It is on average nearly half the team that changes.

More encouragingly, there is a bigger difference between the first and last game of the same season; 4.8 of the same player on average


Same players
Milwall04/08/2023F5DiengMcNairFryLenihanCoulsonHackneyBarlaserForssCrooksMcGreeRogers
Coventry17/05/2023L4SteffenSmithMcNairLenihanGillesHackneyMowattForssAkpomMcGreeArcher
West Brom30/07/2022F6SteffenDijksteelLenihanBolaJonesCrooksHowsonMcGreeGillesWatmoreAkpom
Preston07/05/2022L5DanielsDijksteelFryMcNairJonesCrooksHowsonMcGreeTavernierWatmoreSporar
Bristol City08/08/2021F5LumleyDijksteelHallFryBolaCrooksHowsonMcNairJonesIkpeazuSpence
Wycombe08/05/2021L6ArcherMcNairHallBolaSpenceHowsonSavilleJohnsonCoulsonWatmoreBolasie
Watford11/09/2020F7BettineliDijksteelHallMcNairSpenceHowsonSavilleTavernierJohnsonFletcherAssombalonga
Sheffield Wed22/07/2020L4StojanovicDijksteelFriendFrySpenceTavernierMcNairSavilleJohnsonFletcherAssombalonga
Luton02/08/2019F7RandolphHowsonAyalaShottonCoulsonWingClaytonMcNairJohnsonFletcherAssombalonga
Rotherham05/05/2019L5RandolphMcNairFlintShottonHowsonWingObi MikelBesicSavilleFletcherAssombalonga
Milwall04/08/2018F
RandolphShottonFlintFryFriendClaytonLeadbitterHowsonDowningAssombalongaBraithwaite
Does Coulson count? Should we sign Asssombalonga? Jones & Akpom are still here..
 
Since half the team is always on loan, of course there can be no continuity from season to season since the loans come to an end. It's a bit of a joke really.
 
After Saturday Newy, I’m inclined to go with one of your fantasy teams, desperate times call for desperate measures, cometh the hour and all that.
——————Dieng——————
Williams—Fry—Lenihan—Cox
——-Hackney—Dobson———
—-Forss—Chaplin—Sibley—
——————Meijer————
 
So only having 5 of the same players saturday vs the last playoff game against Coventry was not that extraordinary. It is on average nearly half the team that changes.
It wasn't extraordinary but it just proves that there is no long term thinking from the club and we have been **** poor at recruitment for a long time. We flip flop from manager/style, fill up on loan players and then have to start from scratch every year. We need more continuity and an established group of reliable players.
 
Since half the team is always on loan, of course there can be no continuity from season to season since the loans come to an end. It's a bit of a joke really.
Yep we can kiss goodbye to the autos we are always playing catchup with this flawed strategy
 
Back
Top