Wow. Latest Hartlepool polling...

Corbyn was not given a chance to begin with. Shame on those in the PLP, who knew him, worked with him and judged he would be a disaster. Regardless that they were right, shame on them.

2017 was one in the eye for them. However a lot of Remain people tactically voted Labour, in order to thwart Theresa May and her snap Brexit election, which helped but those votes were then misrepresented by Corbyn's inner circle as a vote for Brexit, thus alienating them for the future. We saw that in the European elections and in 2019. 2017 was still a loss when even by then a majority of the country thought Leaving the EU was a mistake.

Corbyn lost three elections and a referendum, the 2016 local elections were meh, 2017's were better but there was a substantial London element to that. Locally, for an opposition leader, Corbyn should have done better. Miliband had much more of an impact in 2014, for instance.

Corbyn was a nice bloke, decent policies on the whole, bad choice of friends/advisors, blind spot handling the Jewish issue, but ultimately just not a good leader. The PLP were bang out of order in 2015/16, but they were also right.

An unbelievable post. I really hope there is no one in Labour with this line of thinking. In what world were you living when at any point a 'majority' thought leaving the UK was bad??! If anything people became more staunch in their views. Utterly bizarre. I can only assume your reference is people you know personally and assume you're not North East based?
 
An unbelievable post. I really hope there is no one in Labour with this line of thinking. In what world were you living when at any point a 'majority' thought leaving the UK was bad??! If anything people became more staunch in their views. Utterly bizarre. I can only assume your reference is people you know personally and assume you're not North East based?

I am north east based. I can't say I knew them personally, but there were two marches on London with 1 million people and 6 million signed an online petition, remember? Farage's march to leave got about 60 people on it and one of them was curious me. Have you forgotten how pro EU parties got more votes than ConBrexit parties at the European elections.

But if you really want to know why I think a majority of the country realised leaving the EU was a mistake, the evidence is in the polls.

From July 2017, a year after the referendum, right up until 31 January 2020, the date we actually irrevocably left, there was only a single poll that had a majority that thought leaving was the right decision, out of about 75 polls. Generally there was a bigger gap than 52-48 as well.

Maybe it is your view that is based only on people you know personally, in fact?

I'm sorry to cite evidence, but presumably you'll accept my view is not 'unbelievable'.
 
I am north east based. I can't say I knew them personally, but there were two marches on London with 1 million people and 6 million signed an online petition, remember? Farage's march to leave got about 60 people on it and one of them was curious me. Have you forgotten how pro EU parties got more votes than ConBrexit parties at the European elections.

But if you really want to know why I think a majority of the country realised leaving the EU was a mistake, the evidence is in the polls.

From July 2017, a year after the referendum, right up until 31 January 2020, the date we actually irrevocably left, there was only a single poll that had a majority that thought leaving was the right decision, out of about 75 polls. Generally there was a bigger gap than 52-48 as well.

Maybe it is your view that is based only on people you know personally, in fact?

I'm sorry to cite evidence, but presumably you'll accept my view is not 'unbelievable'.

And yet here we are with a massive majority conservative government who electioneered primarily on a Brexit commitment.

The 2nd ref / remain Labour leadership and remain Lib Dems nowhere. Strange isnt it...
 
I am north east based. I can't say I knew them personally, but there were two marches on London with 1 million people and 6 million signed an online petition, remember?
17.4 Million voted to Leave in the 2016 Brexit Ref, remember? .... your 1 million and 6 million figures means nothing
 
The cult of brexit is massive in hartlepool
There are three reasons for voting Brexit that I have come across
1. Disaster capitalists expecting to make/retain money as a consequence
2. Hatred of foreigners
3. Sold a lie that things will return to “the good old days of the 1960s“. And if it doesn’t , and it won’t, at least it would have p1ssed off lots of others too.

Don't think I have missed anything
 
There are three reasons for voting Brexit that I have come across
1. Disaster capitalists expecting to make/retain money as a consequence
2. Hatred of foreigners
3. Sold a lie that things will return to “the good old days of the 1960s“. And if it doesn’t , and it won’t, at least it would have p1ssed off lots of others too.

Don't think I have missed anything

I think you have. It was an anti-Westminster vote for some. The leaders of the Conservatives, Labour, the Lib Dems, the SNP, Plaid, and the Greens were all telling people to remain. From the 2017 election onwards it looked like the tories would lose more seats at the next election. Then after May went and Boris took over he turned brexit in to a Tories vs Westminster battle when he prorogued Parliament and sacked 25 odd of his own MPs. After that the tories surged ahead and cleaned up.
 
And yet here we are with a massive majority conservative government who electioneered primarily on a Brexit commitment.

The 2nd ref / remain Labour leadership and remain Lib Dems nowhere. Strange isnt it...

There it comes down to the first past the post system combined with a wishy washy confused Labour message, an unelectable leader and a failure to form a 2nd referendum electoral alliance.

Labour voters overwhelmingly wanted to Remain. Labour members even more overwhelmingly wanted to Remain. Corbyn’s inner circle did not. They did to the Party and the country what the PLP tried to do to Corbyn in 2015/16.
 
17.4 Million voted to Leave in the 2016 Brexit Ref, remember? .... your 1 million and 6 million figures means nothing

They demonstrate exactly why, combined with the polls, we didn’t get a second referendum. Brexiters simply weren’t interested in the will of the people after all. We are doing what a mere 35% of leave voters wanted in June 2016. 66m doing what 6m want. A very ill informed, misled, largely consequence free 6m at that.
 
Johnson wouldnt have the balls now to go with the electorate.
He has locked the door firmly behind him and heaped schitt on the people outside.
His aim and those around him was not a positive one, of achieving power to "do good", but to fend off the tide of feeling to end austerity and a significant leap left-wards in mainstream politics.
Having achieved his Parliamentary aim - his objectives - ie using Brexit as a tool and a lever to power - is no longer relevant.
1620330124468.png

Orwell, amongst others, summons up the current British domestic political situation quite accurately:
1620330362030.png

The point being, the "oxygen" which fuels the fires of corruption and power will, by its very nature lead to more greed and lust for more power - ultimately the fires will become starved of oxygen and those who lived off it will become forgotten men - despised by those who were gullible and hood-winked enough to believe them.
 
Just back from hartlepool, big queues at the polling stations I saw, not sure if that favours anyone
 
Just back from hartlepool, big queues at the polling stations I saw, not sure if that favours anyone
I always though longer queues favoured Labour as Tories were much more likely to use postal votes. I sincerely hope the long queues are mostly Labour supporters - I can't see a Labour victory sadly but I really hope we do.
 
I think you have. It was an anti-Westminster vote for some. The leaders of the Conservatives, Labour, the Lib Dems, the SNP, Plaid, and the Greens were all telling people to remain. From the 2017 election onwards it looked like the tories would lose more seats at the next election. Then after May went and Boris took over he turned brexit in to a Tories vs Westminster battle when he prorogued Parliament and sacked 25 odd of his own MPs. After that the tories surged ahead and cleaned up.
Think that one could be put in the No 3 locker. Let’s just call it daft.
 
There's definitely more to it than just Brexit alone, but it's definitely looking like a massive own goal to have picked Paul Williams for this by-election.

You could see the issue of his selection a mile off, so I'm surprised that Labour went for him.

Think I'm losing my £10 on a Labour win in the morning, hopefully I wake up to a surprise Hold.
 
There are three reasons for voting Brexit that I have come across
1. Disaster capitalists expecting to make/retain money as a consequence
2. Hatred of foreigners
3. Sold a lie that things will return to “the good old days of the 1960s“. And if it doesn’t , and it won’t, at least it would have p1ssed off lots of others too.

Don't think I have missed anything
How many 'disaster capitalists' do you think are out there? A few, for sure, but not tens of thousands and definitely not hundreds of thousands.

Hatred of foreigners? Again, some but not huge numbers.

Maybe a return to the 1960s, but that also seems an unlikely vote winner because to remember the 1960s properly you'd have to be at least 75 by the time of the 2017 referendum. I wonder if enough people thought the 1960s were that good to make a difference.

Perhaps it's more about people believing that the UK could make its own way in the 21st century because there's a big, motivated workforce that can make things and deliver services without the bureaucratic EU involvement. I have no idea whether that's the case, or not, but this desire for self determinism is a powerful tool.
 
I live in Hartlepool and voted this evening - there were long queues.

Some of that was down to having 4 different ballots to cast and the ballot paper for MP being as long as your arm. COVID restrictions also didn't help with my polling place only having 2 booths.
 
There's definitely more to it than just Brexit alone, but it's definitely looking like a massive own goal to have picked Paul Williams for this by-election.

You could see the issue of his selection a mile off, so I'm surprised that Labour went for him.

Think I'm losing my £10 on a Labour win in the morning, hopefully I wake up to a surprise Hold.
I wonder who enforced his selection?

As per reports at the time the local Labour Party had a list drawn up... he wasn’t on it.

he was campaigning for the PCC (which to be honest he was/should have been a shoe in for it)

Then the next thing you know he is the one and only candidate in Hartlepool and the local Labour Party made it clear it want their decision

Looks like a massive own goal for Labour and he has egg on his face for not getting either role.
 
I wonder who enforced his selection?

As per reports at the time the local Labour Party had a list drawn up... he wasn’t on it.

he was campaigning for the PCC (which to be honest he was/should have been a shoe in for it)

Then the next thing you know he is the one and only candidate in Hartlepool and the local Labour Party made it clear it want their decision

Looks like a massive own goal for Labour and he has egg on his face for not getting either role.
As a member of the Hartlepool CLP I can tell you it was a selection imposed upon us and although I think he'd be a great MP I think it was outrageously stupid to nominate him for Hartlepool.
 
Back
Top