No its a fair point, I certainly don't want to spend millions on duffers. I just think we're very short in the most vital position and could do with at least 1 other option prior to the season starting.Could it not just be that instead of panic buying another carthorse to make the numbers up we are actually trying to but proven quality players and their existing clubs are either digging their heels in and there are further negotiations to be had, liekly to take us up to transfer deadline or are waiting to get replacement players in before allowing our target to leave. Surely we are better off with a couple of quality strikers for 40 games of the season than a couple of duffers for 46.
Or am I being too optimistic?
It's not that difficult to understand that what you've put there isn't what I said, you're totally misrepresenting the conversation here.If you read the post I clearly identify it as my opinion on the view that footballers careers are short and they deserve millions just to compensate.
Its not that difficult to understand - and its not specific to one player.
Please read whats written first
agreed, the issue has been compounded from the Britt era. We spent a fortune on a dud, an overrated kid and a stroppy danish lad.Defensively we will be sound, no issues.
GK is sorted
MF will perform well
Forwards........
You're refusing to be willfully pessimistic, that's the problem.Could it not just be that instead of panic buying another carthorse to make the numbers up we are actually trying to but proven quality players and their existing clubs are either digging their heels in and there are further negotiations to be had, liekly to take us up to transfer deadline or are waiting to get replacement players in before allowing our target to leave. Surely we are better off with a couple of quality strikers for 40 games of the season than a couple of duffers for 46.
Or am I being too optimistic?
Fully agree. Below is the list of players we have that you'd expect to actually get on the pitch. Nobody else in the squad is near. It is incredibly light. If you go by 2 players for each position we are 7 players short, probably 8 because we'd like 5 strikers.Why do people think 12 outfield players has us sorted in positions ?
What about injuries? Loss of form? Suspension?
Or fielding a bench???
Why do people think 12 outfield players has us sorted in positions ?
Fully agree. Below is the list of players we have that you'd expect to actually get on the pitch. Nobody else in the squad is near. It is incredibly light. If you go by 2 players for each position we are 7 players short, probably 8 because we'd like 5 strikers.
RWB - Jones
CB - Dijksteel, McNair, Fry, Lenihan
LWB - Giles, Bola
CM - Tav, Crooks, Howson, McGree
CF - Watmore, Coburn
Fully agree. Below is the list of players we have that you'd expect to actually get on the pitch. Nobody else in the squad is near. It is incredibly light. If you go by 2 players for each position we are 7 players short, probably 8 because we'd like 5 strikers.
RWB - Jones
CB - Dijksteel, McNair, Fry, Lenihan
LWB - Giles, Bola
CM - Tav, Crooks, Howson, McGree
CF - Watmore, Coburn
Bilongo, Hackney? Plus naming a player that doesn’t play for us (albeit he’s on trial).Because we have more than 12 outfield players.
With Smith (who we've probably signed), there's 14 squad - Fry, McNair, Dijksteel, Lenihan, Giles, Bola, Jones, Smith, Howson, Tavernier, McGree, Crooks, Watmore, Coburn
Boyd-Munce will be included in the squad, he's been around the team since he came in, and rightly so - there's 15.
We have incorporated youth players in the squads before, how else are Fry, Tav, Jones, Coburn in the above list... I think Bilongo and Hackney are both comfortable additions - there's 17 players.
CBs - Dijksteel/McNair/Lenihan - Fry/Lenihan - McNair/Bilongo - Sorted (a left footed LCB would help, but I don't think it's something we're desperate for).
RWB - Jones/Smith - Cover can come from Dijksteel or Howson - Sorted
LWB - Giles/Bola - Cover can come from Tav or Bilongo - Sorted
CDM - Howson/Hackney - Cover can come from McNair or Crooks - Sorted (maybe slightly weak here, but again... we don't "need" anyone else here).
CM - Crooks, Tavernier, McGree, Boyd-Munce - Sorted
We NEED two strikers. Three would be perfect, but realistically, two is "enough".
Bilongo, Hackney? Plus naming a player that doesn’t play for us (albeit he’s on trial).
13 outfield (first team) players. Hey if you’re ok with that then fine, it’s just many aren’t ok with it. The manager being one.
CW has said he doesn't expect the young lads to feature much, on the bench 1 or 2 if they have to, but they won't feature so that leaves us light
Keepers - Steffen, Roberts, Daniels
Right backs - Jones, Smith
Centre backs - Dijksteel, McNair, Fry, Lenihan
Left backs- Giles, Bola, Coulson
Centre mid - Tavernier, Crooks, McGree, Howson
Strikers - Watmore, Coburn
I can see Kavanagh, Bilongo and Boyd-Munce been the 3 that fill the gaps on the bench, but i doubt any will start many games whatsoever, or even come off the bench unless absolutely necessary.
CW has said he doesn't expect the young lads to feature much, on the bench 1 or 2 if they have to, but they won't feature so that leaves us light
Keepers - Steffen, Roberts, Daniels
Right backs - Jones, Smith
Centre backs - Dijksteel, McNair, Fry, Lenihan
Left backs- Giles, Bola, Coulson
Centre mid - Tavernier, Crooks, McGree, Howson
Strikers - Watmore, Coburn
I can see Kavanagh, Bilongo and Boyd-Munce been the 3 that fill the gaps on the bench, but i doubt any will start many games whatsoever, or even come off the bench unless absolutely necessary.
Including Boyd-Munce, Bilongo, Hackney and Finch in our first team plans as players that will be involved shows how light we are. Those players should be nowhere near the first team picture of a team looking to get promoted out of the Championship (which Wilder has said was the only thing he came here to do).
Finch definitely won't be included, I think he's only 17 and Kavanagh will be ahead of him.
However, not including Boyd-Munce and maybe Bilongo... without hindsight, would be the same as not including Coburn and Jones in our squad last season.
It's makes it harder to get rid of him if he hasn't had a pre season so he should be included anyway.Get Uche in until we sign forwards!
I’d rather have him as an option that nothing at all
Terrible decision not to include him in pre season
I'm putting Coburn in that bracket too. He's there at the moment through necessity because we have nobody else, not because he's going to fire us to promotion.
We need better strikers than Josh Coburn in that first team if we're serious about challenging to get out of this league, and we need them right now.
It's makes it harder to get rid of him if he hasn't had a pre season so he should be included anyway.