Name one player you like who was signed from each manager since you've been going - Not re-signed new contract

Erimus74

Erimus74

Well-known member
here comes the rain, da,da, da, da

Stan Anderson - John Hickton

Jack Charlton - Bobby Murdoch

John Neal - Terry Cochrane

Bobby Murdoch - Heine Otto

Malcolm Allison - Stephen Pears

Willie Maddren - Bernie Slaven

Bruce Rioch - Dean Glover

Colin Todd - Robbie Mustoe

Lennie Lawrence - Paul Wilkinson

Bryan Robson - Juninho

Steve McLaren - Viduka

Gareth Southgate - Young

Gordon Strachan - Robson

Tony Mowbray - Grant Leadbitter

Aitor Karanka - Traore

Monk - Jonny Howson

Pulis & Woodgate ?????
 
Steve McClaren - Jimmy Floyd

Gareth Southgate - Didier Digard

Gordon Strachan - Barry Robson

Tony Mowbray - Emanuel Ledesma

Aitor Karanka - Christian Stuani

Garry Monk - Ashley Fletcher

Tony Pulis - George Saville

Jonathan Woodgate - Patrick Roberts (Loan)
 
Dont think I could add to either, interesting B21 Manny Ledesma I liked him myself, maybe Tomlin over Traore as I wasn't a fan of Traore spent most of his time on his backside and was gormless for most part. Although Pullis did guide him.... But we made a few quid.I

I liked Tomlin.
 
ticker_tape said:
Dont think I could add to either, interesting B21 Manny Ledesma I liked him myself, maybe Tomlin over Traore as I wasn't a fan of Traore spent most of his time on his backside and was gormless for most part. Although Pullis did guide him.... But we made a few quid.I

I liked Tomlin.
Click to expand...

Yeah he was alright Ledesma, could be hit and miss but found him
Enjoyable to watch and he had the odd flash off brilliance
 
Block21 said:
Yeah he was alright Ledesma, could be hit and miss but found him
Enjoyable to watch and he had the odd flash off brilliance
Click to expand...
I'm not very good at statistics and dates but I didn't notice Tomlin, Ian Gibson, Mcmordie,Chadwick, O'Rourke and Branco on your list Erimus!?
 
ticker_tape said:
Dont think I could add to either, interesting B21 Manny Ledesma I liked him myself, maybe Tomlin over Traore as I wasn't a fan of Traore spent most of his time on his backside and was gormless for most part. Although Pullis did guide him.... But we made a few quid.I

I liked Tomlin.
Click to expand...
I was going to go for Tomlin too ticker, who was a touch of brilliance about him & could also be lost in a game, my reason for Traore was how he turned out & rightly so the credit goes to Pulis who done a great job on him
 
Robbo - Juninho
McClaren - Viduka
Southgate - Huth
Strachan - Barry Robson
Mogga - Adomah
Karanka - Traore
Monk - Randolph
Pulis - McNair
Woodgate - o_O
 
Block21 said:
Steve McClaren - Jimmy Floyd

Gareth Southgate - Didier Digard

Gordon Strachan - Barry Robson

Tony Mowbray - Emanuel Ledesma

Aitor Karanka - Christian Stuani

Garry Monk - Ashley Fletcher

Tony Pulis - George Saville

Jonathan Woodgate - Patrick Roberts (Loan)
Click to expand...
Stuani was a good signing, but played in his favoured role could have awesome
 
Johnny Hendrie deserves a mention, signed by Todd iirc, but came into his own under Lennie. I always liked Brian Laws too, signed by Willie and great under Brucie until he got injured. Venables only signing Dean Windass was also a bit of a personal favourite too.

I was always disappointed Karanka didn't keep Jelle Vossen or Tomlin. Otherwise my list is similar to Erimus.

Neal - Cochrane
Murdoch - Otto
Allison - Pears
Maddren - Slaven
Rioch - Glover
Todd - Hendrie
Lennie - Wilkinson
Robbo - Juninho
Venables- Windass
McLaren- Viduka
Southgate- Young
Strachan - Robson
Mowbray- Friend
Karanka- Bamford
Monk - Fletcher
Pulis - McNair
Woodgate - Roberts
 
Otto42 said:
Johnny Hendrie deserves a mention, signed by Todd iirc, but came into his own under Lennie. I always liked Brian Laws too, signed by Willie and great under Brucie until he got injured. Venables only signing Dean Windass was also a bit of a personal favourite too.

I was always disappointed Karanka didn't keep Jelle Vossen or Tomlin. Otherwise my list is similar to Erimus.

Neal - Cochrane
Murdoch - Otto
Allison - Pears
Maddren - Slaven
Rioch - Glover
Todd - Hendrie
Lennie - Wilkinson
Robbo - Juninho
Venables- Windass
McLaren- Viduka
Southgate- Young
Strachan - Robson
Mowbray- Friend
Karanka- Bamford
Monk - Fletcher
Pulis - McNair
Woodgate - Roberts
Click to expand...
With Maddren & Mogga you can could a few names from who they signed

Agree toss of a coin between Hendrie & Mustoe
 
Carter McMordie
Anderson Souness
Charlton Murdoch
Neal. Cochrane
Murdoch. Otto
Allison. Pears
Maddren Slaven
Rioch Kerr
Todd. Hendrie
Lawrence Wilkinson
Robson Juninho
McClaran Viduka
Southgate. Tuncay
Strachan. Robson
Mowbray. Adomah
Karanka Downing
Monk Howson
Pulis McNair
Woodgate Roberts
 
Charlton (manager when I first went) Terry Cooper
Neal - Cochrane
Murdoch - Otto (cant think of any other good ones)
Allison - Paul Sugrue (didnt think he was very good but Pears only on loan. Considered Beattie as he was unbeaten in the games he started but only 4 of them)
Maddren - has to be Slaven (though Pears would be close)
Rioch - Kerr (I did consider Trevor Senior for those goals in the play offs alone)
Todd - Hendrie as he was one of my favourite signings of pre Robson era
Lawrence - Willie Falconer as I thought he was brilliant until that injury at start of premier league season

Robson - Juninho
McClaren - Southgate
Southgate - Woodgate
Strachan - Robson was the best of a bad lot, but still didn't really rate him always remember that penalty in last minute v Portsmouth

Mowbray - Friend
Karanka - Traore (even though he obviously didn't really trust him)
Monk - Assombalonga (he was too expensive but he has scored a consistent number of goals)
Pullis - missing out on Bolassie was the best bit of transfer business he did.
Woodgate - sorry none
 
junos_boots said:
Charlton (manager when I first went) Terry Cooper
Neal - Cochrane
Murdoch - Otto (cant think of any other good ones)
Allison - Paul Sugrue (didnt think he was very good but Pears only on loan. Considered Beattie as he was unbeaten in the games he started but only 4 of them)
Maddren - has to be Slaven (though Pears would be close)
Rioch - Kerr (I did consider Trevor Senior for those goals in the play offs alone)
Todd - Hendrie as he was one of my favourite signings of pre Robson era
Lawrence - Willie Falconer as I thought he was brilliant until that injury at start of premier league season

Robson - Juninho
McClaren - Southgate
Southgate - Woodgate
Strachan - Robson was the best of a bad lot, but still didn't really rate him always remember that penalty in last minute v Portsmouth

Mowbray - Friend
Karanka - Traore (even though he obviously didn't really trust him)
Monk - Assombalonga (he was too expensive but he has scored a consistent number of goals)
Pullis - missing out on Bolassie was the best bit of transfer business he did.
Woodgate - sorry none
Click to expand...
junos_boots, agree with all that, including your Malcolm Allison comments
 
Allison - Pears
Maddren - Slaven
Rioch - Glover
Todd - Hendrie
Lennie - Wilkinson
Robson- Juninho
McClaren - Southgate
Southgate- Woodgate
Strachan - Robson
Mowbray- Friend
Karanka- Bamford
Monk - Randolph
Pulis - McNair
Woodgate - Roberts
 
Colin Todd - Robbie Mustoe

Lennie Lawrence - Craig Hignett

Bryan Robson - Juninho

Steve McLaren - Viduka

Gareth Southgate - Young

Gordon Strachan - Robson

Tony Mowbray - Grant Leadbitter

Aitor Karanka - Traore

Monk - Jonny Howson

Pulis - McNair

& Woodgate ?????

Same as erimus but with a couple of exceptions.
Funny how the last few didn't play their best football under the manager who signed them.
 
Stan Anderson - Souness

Jack Charlton - Murdoch

John Neal - Cochrane

Bobby Murdoch - Otto

Malcolm Allison - Pears

Willie Maddren - Slaven

Bruce Rioch - Kerr

Colin Todd - Mustoe

Lennie Lawrence - Falconer

Bryan Robson - Juninho

Steve McLaren - Viduka

Gareth Southgate - Huth

Gordon Strachan - Robson

Tony Mowbray - Ayala (deal was done)

Aitor Karanka - Bamford

Monk - Jonny Howson

Pulis - McNair

Woodgate - Stojanovic
 
coluka said:
Stan Anderson - Souness

Jack Charlton - Murdoch

John Neal - Cochrane

Bobby Murdoch - Otto

Malcolm Allison - Pears

Willie Maddren - Slaven

Bruce Rioch - Kerr

Colin Todd - Mustoe

Lennie Lawrence - Falconer

Bryan Robson - Juninho

Steve McLaren - Viduka

Gareth Southgate - Huth

Gordon Strachan - Robson

Tony Mowbray - Ayala (deal was done)

Aitor Karanka - Bamford

Monk - Jonny Howson

Pulis - McNair

Woodgate - Stojanovic
Click to expand...
Another good un from Mogga, he certainly laid the foundations for Aitor
 
Based on E74's list

I would use all his choices except:

Todd - Hendrie just over Mustoe

Lennie - Hignett

Smac - Southgate

Mogga - Ayala

Pulis - McNair

Woody - He's had no money.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top