Air India Flight to Gatwick crash - unconfirmed 242 on board

Neither pilot said they touched them
True, but if one of them had deliberately taken an action that would condemn 270 people to their deaths, would you expect them to just admit it? Because I wouldn't.

If it was deliberate (and we still don't know that 100% for sure, although it seems a likely explanation) what would you expect the guy to say -"Yeah, you got me, I'm trying to kill us all."?
 
Neither pilot said they touched them

True, but if one of them had deliberately taken an action that would condemn 270 people to their deaths, would you expect them to just admit it? Because I wouldn't.

If it was deliberate (and we still don't know that 100% for sure, although it seems a likely explanation) what would you expect the guy to say -"Yeah, you got me, I'm trying to kill us all."?
agreed in my opinion ‘why did you cutoff’ is enough to me for it to be acknowledgement of

A. Trying to take attention away from an action you did yourself
B. Acknowledging something you saw

If the switches had say vibrated out of position you would seek to understand why they had rather than accuse with the statement you heard
 
some commenters with more details, on YT vids where captains of these planes are discussing the the only 2 remaining explanation, accident swithc movement or suicide

"There were two pilots Captain Sumeet Sabharwal and copilot Clive Kunder. Apparently Clive Kunder was in control of the flight. Sumeet Sabharwal was 60 years old, unmarried, about to retire and had lost his aged mother recently. Clive Kunder was a young pilot (20s), recently engaged and was going to be married in a couple of months. You figure out the rest"

"I agree, it was the Captain committing suicide. The captain gaslighted the CVR by accusing the FO. Great analysis Dan."

Indian culture, it's considered too awful to be known to be a mass suicider so all attempts are made to make it unsolvable or bring another under the main suspicion.

They are saying the Mayday call by the older captain was too pragmatic to rehearsed , not a real life emotion to it, sort of get it out, just for the record

As the captains are discussing, why ask "Why did you switch off. " you don't do that , you just correct the situation and discuss later . The young pilot was too focused with all take off duties to even reach over and do that .
 
I’d expect them to look into the debt situation of the pilots involved and any large life insurance potential too. Given the conversation so far published. Personally, I’d hazard a guess that the person who asked the other why he moved the switches was more likely the one who did (if it really happened at all manually) to divert attention.
 
Some information being leaked into the press around who was talking

Pilot is apparently the one who is likely to have flicked the switch

It was the first officer who asked and is apparently started to panic while the pilot remained calm in responding he didn’t
 
Some information being leaked into the press around who was talking

Pilot is apparently the one who is likely to have flicked the switch

It was the first officer who asked and is apparently started to panic while the pilot remained calm in responding he didn’t
Surely both pilots' financial situation, live insurance cover and mental health must have been looked into by now?
Maybe Modi is trying to instigate a cover-up if it looks bad for India. He is after all a nationalist authoritarian/sectarian.
 
Surely both pilots' financial situation, live insurance cover and mental health must have been looked into by now?
Maybe Modi is trying to instigate a cover-up if it looks bad for India. He is after all a nationalist authoritarian/sectarian.
The article I read said it it was in America criminal proceedings would have been opened
 
Also (I'm currently in India) they're reporting here a wider issue with the switches which has been possibly brushed under the carpet .
 
Also (I'm currently in India) they're reporting here a wider issue with the switches which has been possibly brushed under the carpet .
On the Australian news it was the view of a pilot that the switches are mechanical and an electric fault couldn’t be the cause

What’s the wider issue that’s been reported
 
On the Australian news it was the view of a pilot that the switches are mechanical and an electric fault couldn’t be the cause

What’s the wider issue that’s been reported
Just what I said above A wider issue with the switches being possibly faulty and that they'd known for a while. Also the wider issue being a fleet wide problem if it's found to be the case.
 
Back
Top