The "inexperienced" argument doesn't wash with me.
There's obviously exceptions to the below like Woodgate, and i know there's a lot more arguments to what i'm saying, but.....
EXPERIENCED:
Pulis: Did ok one season, mainly because of traore. Disgusting to watch towards the end.
Warnock: Kept us up in those last 10 games, went quickly downhill after that.
Wilder: Did ok at first but form fell off a cliff at the start of the calendar year imo.
INEXPERIENCED:
Southgate: Did ok for 2 seasons, probably made some poor transfer decisions but i think he would have took us back up.
Mclaren: Our most successful manager
Karanka: Most enjoyable 2 seasons in recent times. He was the one who got us promoted after so many failed.
All i'm trying to say is, i'm not buying into the whole "too inexperienced" stuff as it's been proved with recent managers it's not exactly the case.
I'm all for giving Carrick a chance personally.
I've had enough of the "experienced" ones coming in and stinking the place out to be quite honest.